THE ROBERT W. WHITAKER ARCHIVE

PETER WAS RIGHT, I WAS WRONG | 2004-12-13

I never understood why it HURTS people so much to say something as simple as "He was right and I was wrong." Even people MY age have trouble with that.

Peter said that Zoroastrianis was the monotheization (?) of the Old Aryan religion of Mazdaism. Just as the Jews had their own God JHWH but took others for granted, Aryans had a chief god Mazda. Mazda became the Only God with the prophet Zoroaster about 1200 BC. JHWH became the Only God and the Good God of the Jews a great deal later.

In the meantime the Jews had a LOT of contact with Persia, including living there.

My mistake was in mixing up Mithraism with Mazdaism. Since I'm pretending to be able to handle all these big words and theological constructs, this should embarrass me greatly.

Sorry, I'm all embarrassed out. As I just pointed out below, you can't find out if you're wrong unless you SAY it. From Peter's explanation, I have learned yet more about the Mazda-JHWH connection.

And I wouldn't have learned that if I hadn't been wrong, and I wouldn't have learned that if I hadn't SAID it and then sat back and taken the heat.

COMMENTS (4)

#1 Peter | 2004-12-13 18:34

Well, thanks for all the compliments, Bob. Flatter me all you like, I like it.

However, I have this sneaking suspicion that most of your mistakes are made on purpose to see who is reading you closely.

You are, after all, The Greatest Writer That Ever Lived, you know.

#2 Bob Whitaker | 2004-12-15 15:24

Peter, enjoy it while you can. You know damned well that when Ole Bob compliments you, you are going to catch it later on.

#3 Richard L. Hardison | 2004-12-15 20:37

Peter, take Bob's word for it. YOU ARE IN TROUBLE NOW! Don't bother running, you'll only die tired.

#4 Peter | 2004-12-15 21:58

I guess I should just surrender while I still can.